This one simple change improved Motivated Seller site conversions by 29.55% overnight

Last updated on

real estate investor website conversions
Real live test results from a motivated seller site. What small but powerful change did we make to this site to boost conversions by almost 30% overnight? See below…

This article is the second in our Carrot Test Kitchen series – it’s a series of posts that help you to dissect the secret recipes we use to generate thousands of leads for real estate investors across hundreds of websites around the USA.

Welcome back to the Carrot Test Kitchen!

Today we’ll be sharing one change that made a huge difference – just this little fix almost doubled conversions on the site where we tested it.

As you know, Carrot is totally customizable – so we get lots of variations throughout the system with our customers. We love to test these variations to find out more about what works to convert site visitors into real, genuine leads.

This could be motivated sellers of real estate, cash buyers, private lenders, tenant buyers for rent to own, etc.

This one simple change improved Motivated Seller site conversions by 29.55%

In the case of today’s example, that’s certainly the case.

Now, we all know that the buttons are really important… but even we were shocked by the results of this change. A 31% improvement in conversions overnight?  Wow!

Here’s the original (we call it the “Control” in our tests) front page of this motivated seller site:

Motivated Seller site conversions


During the test period (about 45 days) it converted at 10.53%… which is decent… room for improvement but decent. This means just over 1 out of 10 motivated sellers who landed on the site gave this InvestorCarrot member their info about their house.

Here’s the variation we tested:

Motivated Seller site conversions increase


Do you see the difference?

Bigger Action Button + Color Change From
Black To Orange…

We increased the size of the “Click to Continue” button to fill up the form’s window, and we changed the color.

During the test, conversions increased by almost 30% overnight… to 13.64%.

That’s a 29.55% improvement!

Why did this simple button size and color tweak on this motivated real estate seller website increase conversions so much so quickly?

A few reasons to note:

  1. In almost every test we’ve run, and we run a lot, the bigger the “call to action” the higher the conversions. This button is about 5 times larger than the previous black button… so it grabs the website visitors attention right off the bat.
  2. Color Matters A Lot – We can’t say that any particular button color always converts the best on all websites… but we can say that simply testing other button colors can increase results big time.  In this case, we tested Orange instead of black and it saw a big bump. Orange is seen as an “action” color… and grabs the attention more than black.

We’ll also try to test out other button colors to see if we can raise conversions even more on our member’s sites as we go.

Over the next couple of weeks, we’re going to update our default to increase the size of the button on our Carrot member’s websites. This is another HUGE benefit of being a Carrot member… we’re continually testing and tweaking designs and approach conversions from the science side of things.

As we find things that work better that are science-based… we trickle those improvements down to our member’s sites FOR FREE.

If you care about higher conversions… Join Carrot and let us do the testing for you.

We love to see these kinds of results when we run split tests.

They help guide our system-wide improvements so that we can add even better squeeze pages, content, and forms to our member’s sites.

We’ll be upgrading your sites within the next couple of weeks to include a lot of awesome improvements and changes like these that help dramatically increase results for our members.

If you’re not yet a member, jump on board to get these same benefits!

Click here now to see our plans and join!

Aaron McManus

Get weekly inbound online marketing tips, test results, and resources to grow your real estate investment business

  • This field is for validation purposes and should be left unchanged.

7 responses to “This one simple change improved Motivated Seller site conversions by 29.55% overnight

  1. Awesome Trevor! Google finally just indexed me two days ago. I made the changes and will be ready. This is exactly what puts Investor Carrot miles above the template guys. Thanks!

    1. Awesome! Thanks for the comment Jamane. Ya, it’s amazing what a small tweak can do to increase conversions on your sites eh?

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *